A camera's presence does not establish that it recorded the relevant view or interval.
Short answer
Ask for the video early, and ask for more than the clip of the fall. A request that reaches back before the fall and forward past it, names the cameras, and asks for original files and export details gives the best chance of useful footage.
- A clip from 3:19 to 3:21 (hypothetical fall at 3:20 p.m.), which shows you walking in and going down, and probably nothing about how long the spill had been there.
- A preservation request, which doesn't guarantee the footage exists or give you an immediate right to a copy.
- Missing video, which doesn't prove a claim on its own or entitle anyone to a jury instruction.
- Video for an injured shopper, which can fill in what pain, confusion or a blocked view kept you from seeing.
- Video for a lawyer, whose value depends on what the system actually recorded and how much a lawyer can reliably read from it.
- Related guides: The first 72 hours guide and the full litigation pillar.
Define the question before choosing the interval
Each part of a recording answers a different question, as this hypothetical 3:20 p.m. fall shows.
- 2:20 to 3:19 p.m., which might show the spill appearing, shoppers stepping around it, an employee walking past and a customer reporting it, for notice: how long the hazard was there and whether the store knew.
- 3:19 to 3:21 p.m., which might show the approach and the fall, for the mechanism of the fall.
- 3:21 to 3:50 p.m., which might show employees responding, the cleanup and where witnesses were standing, for witnesses and the condition right afterward.
A clip of the fall alone may show contact and nothing about how long the hazard existed. The right window depends on the theory of the case and on what each camera could see, and no universal number of hours fits every fall.
What the request should include | Hypothetical example |
|---|---|
The store address, department, time, and a fixed landmark | "The frozen pizza case across from the bakery," at about 3:20 p.m. |
Why a second view matters | Camera 12 on the self-checkout corridor shows the approach, while Camera 7 in the aisle shows the floor. |
Who controls outside cameras | If the parking lot cameras belong to the landlord, a letter to the store alone may not protect them. |
Why the window runs from 2:20 to 3:50 rather than 3:00 to 3:30 | A written reason answers a later "overbroad" objection and keeps the request from saving the fall while losing the hour that matters for notice. |
When to adjust the window | Once the store shares a camera map or system details |
Build the request around the grocery location
In a grocery store, the camera directly above the fall may not show the floor at all.
Where else to look when the view is blocked (hypothetical)
- A camera at the far end of the aisle, or one covering the cross-aisle, for a tall refrigerated case between the camera and the floor.
- The view from the next department, which may show where the spill came from, for a seasonal display like a pallet of watermelons.
- The overhead camera for the neighboring lane, for a checkout fixture or bagging stand.
The request should ask which views existed that day, because a visible camera may not have been working, recording, or controlled by the same company at the time. Naming the approach and nearby fixed landmarks helps the store find the right footage.
Timing point | What it means |
|---|---|
Brookshire Brothers, a Texas grocery case | That store's system recorded over itself on a roughly 30-day loop, and the shopper's lawyer asked for 2.5 hours of footage almost a year after the fall [S5] |
- Kroger's own retention schedule, which hasn't been verified for this article, so the request should go out promptly, with no waiting for a presumed overwrite date.
- The 2:20 start of the hypothetical window, since earlier footage may show when the spill appeared, who walked past it and whether anyone inspected the aisle.
- The window running past the fall, since later footage may identify witnesses and the cleanup.
- A fair window length, since a longer window needs a reason in the facts and should stay proportionate to the dispute.
- Tracking, with the delivery of the request and each follow-up logged on separate lines.
Identify custodians and record systems
Video is only one kind of electronic evidence, and each kind may sit with a different custodian (hypothetical map).
- Camera footage and export logs, held by the store's system administrator or an outside security vendor; hold requested, not yet confirmed.
- The incident report and its photo attachments, held by store management or a claims office; requested.
- Employee messages about the spill, on store devices or a messaging system; unknown whether any exist.
- Inspection or floor-walk entries, held by store management; requested.
- A refrigeration work order, held by a maintenance contractor; separate request needed.
The assistant manager who can pull up playback on the office monitor may not control how long the system keeps footage, or be able to save it permanently.
- Watching versus controlling, since being able to watch the video and having legal control of it are different things.
- The hold request, which should go to whoever can actually place a hold, whether that turns out to be a store administrator, a company security office or an outside vendor.
- Records that may not exist, since a national retailer's size doesn't prove that a particular store logs floor walks electronically or that employees messaged each other about the spill.
- The request, which should cover what the store actually uses or what investigation reasonably identifies.
- The map, which shows which searches are finished and which questions are still open.
- Related companies, since the map keeps a family of companies from being treated as one custodian, while the control and discovery rules still decide who must produce what.
Preserve original exports and understandable copies
Ask for native or original-format exports where they're reasonably available, plus any player software and the system's export report.
Version of the video | What it keeps | What it can lose |
|---|---|---|
A native export in the system's own format | Metadata, full image quality, and frame timing | It may need the vendor's player software to open. |
A screen recording of playback | The basic picture, which may still be informative | Metadata and quality, and it can change frame timing, so its limits should be written down and it should never be labeled "original video" |
A phone video forwarded through a messaging app | A viewable copy | Quality and the original filename, so ask the sender for the original file instead of screenshots |

- Leaving the received files alone and reviewing copies, so the original stays exactly as it arrived.
- Logging the source, the date, the filenames and every hand-off, so anyone can trace how each copy was made.
- Recording a checksum on day one, which can show that a file hasn't changed since, but not that Camera 7's clock was right or that the export includes every frame the system recorded.
- Keeping a client's original phone video and noting the phone model, so it shows how each copy relates to the first recording.
A practical export review protocol
Here is what a handling log might say for the hypothetical, step by step.
- Logging the delivery (step 1), as in "Two .avi files from the claims office, received June 3; they need the vendor's player".
- Comparing it with the request (step 2), as in "Asked for Cameras 7 and 12, 2:20 to 3:50; received Camera 7, 3:15 to 3:25 only".
- Hashing the original (step 3), as in "SHA-256 checksum recorded at 10:14 a.m. and stored with the log".
- Making a working copy (step 4), as in "Copy A made for review; original moved to the evidence folder".
- Testing playback (step 5), as in "Copy A plays at normal speed; original not opened".
- Labeling working aids (step 6), as in "Still at 3:19:52, enlarged four times, marked WORKING AID; normal-speed clip kept with it".
Zooming in on a frame won't recover detail the camera never captured.
- An enlarged still, which can't add detail the camera never recorded.
- A video expert's testimony, which can explain compression or dropped frames, but shouldn't point to a grape or a puddle that isn't actually visible.
- Any demonstrative offered in court, which needs a foundation under the applicable evidence rules [S7] [S11].
Test clocks continuity and visibility
Four checks catch most timing problems, shown here with hypothetical examples.
- The clock, by asking whether the overlay matches an independent event, such as Camera 7 showing 3:10 p.m. for a sale the receipt prints at 3:14.
- Daylight saving, by asking whether the clock was adjusted and by whom, such as footage from early November that runs an hour off.
- Continuity, by asking whether the system records continuously or only on motion, such as a clip that jumps from 3:02 to 3:09 with no explanation.
- Visibility, by asking whether the floor can be seen at all, such as a pallet of bottled water that blocks the spot until 3:19.
Camera 7 and Camera 12 may not agree, since someone may have reset one by hand after the time change, and export software can display time differently again.
Issues, and how to handle each
- An offset between clocks, which you note only when the evidence supports it.
- A gap like 3:02 to 3:09, where ordinary causes include motion-triggered recording, an export cut short, dropped frames or a pallet in the way, so the next step is to ask how the system works and check its logs or a custodian's testimony.
- Calling the gap deletion, though a jump isn't, by itself, proof that someone deleted footage.
- Calling the gap harmless, which it isn't until someone has considered what those seven minutes might have shown about the disputed issue.
- Visibility, since a camera can record the aisle all afternoon and never show clear liquid on white tile, and a display can hide the spot until the fall, so say what's visible and what isn't.
- Proof of duration, which the notice article covers, including how these limits affect proof of how long a hazard existed.
Match the camera clock to independent anchors
Take a 3:14 p.m. receipt, a shopper who remembers falling just before paying, and a 3:10 image of her at a register.
- The camera clock runs four minutes slow, confirmed by the same offset on other known events, like the 6:00 a.m. opening.
- The shopper remembers the order of events differently, confirmed by a witness, or another camera view showing when the fall happened.
- The 3:10 image shows someone else's transaction, confirmed by the register number and the items on the receipt.
A receipt is a useful comparison point only after the transaction and the person are reliably identified.
Clock question | Why it matters |
|---|---|
Was the camera time synchronized? | An unsynchronized clock drifts from real time. |
Was it changed for daylight saving, or displayed differently in the export software? | Either one can shift every timestamp. |
Which time does the export filename show? | It might be the moment the file was saved, not the event. |
Which clock does a screen recording show? | It can show the reviewer's laptop clock beside the camera overlay. |
Which clock does the timeline use? | Every timeline should say. |
What if the difference can't be resolved? | Use a range and explain it, because when clocks disagree an honest interval is more believable than a neat minute-by-minute sequence. |
A hypothetical recording comparison
Assume a shopper falls beside a display at 3:20 p.m., and three views exist.
- A one-minute lead-in, covering 3:19 to 3:20 p.m., for the approach and the mechanism, with little information about how long the hazard existed.
- An upper-body view, covering 2:50 to 3:30 p.m. and showing people from the waist up, for traffic and employee movements, though the floor may be invisible.
- A floor view, covering 3:05 p.m. onward, for position and observable timing, though what the object is, and how clearly it shows, still need checking.
Suppose the floor view shows an object at 3:08 p.m. and again at the fall, but a cart blocks the area from 3:10 to 3:16.
- Identifying the object, by confirming it's the same object at 3:08 and at the fall and that the view stays clear.
- Handling the gap, by naming the six-minute gap rather than smoothing it into a continuous twelve-minute hazard.
- Building the demonstrative timeline, by marking 3:10 to 3:16 as unknown and citing a source for every entry.
- Avoiding invented visuals, since an object shouldn't be animated where none is visible.
- Proposing a reconstruction, by disclosing its assumptions and getting the necessary evidentiary rulings before anyone shows it as proof.
Distinguish missing footage from footage that cannot answer the question
Two different problems get called "missing video," and they need different follow-up.
Problem | Hypothetical | Follow-up |
|---|---|---|
The clip is complete but can't show the hazard | It shows the fall accurately and nothing about a clear puddle | Treat it as a limit of the image, not necessarily a deletion |
The export is too short | It starts at 3:19 because someone pulled only a short interval | Ask whether the earlier native recording still exists, who chose the interval, and whether anyone reviewed other views; keep the emails about those choices, since the answers may show an ordinary retrieval problem, a disagreement over scope, or a preservation issue that needs a judge |
The Anderson-Brown case came out of a Duncanville Kroger on the morning of May 10, 2020, when a shopper slipped on a puddle in an aisle. [S15]
- A picture of the puddle, which could show the puddle was there after the fall.
- A video that partly shows the fall, which could show that she fell in that spot.
- The store's hours, which could show the store had been open nearly three hours.
None of it showed how long the puddle had been on the floor, and the Fifth Circuit affirmed summary judgment for Kroger in an unpublished opinion that binds no Texas state court.
Propositions a clip might support
- The shopper was in the aisle.
- How the fall happened.
- An employee's route past the spot.
- When the liquid became visible.
- All four at once.
Whether one clip can support each, in the same order.
- Often.
- Sometimes, if the feet are in view.
- Only if the view covers that route.
- Only with a clear, continuous view of the floor.
- Only after checking what the clip actually shows, so a lawyer shouldn't cite one clip for everything.
Draft a preservation request with factual specificity
A preservation request should be adapted by an attorney to the facts of the fall.
- The occurrence and location, covering the fall, the store and the spot in the store.
- The recordings and time window, covering the camera categories and the interval, with the original files and related export information.
- The request itself, that the recipient suspend routine destruction of relevant material within its possession or control, consistent with the applicable duty.
- Follow-up, to confirm delivery and then check whether a hold was actually put in place.
A form letter doesn't make law, and the store may push back on the scope, on who controls the records, or on whether litigation was reasonably anticipated.
- The assumption that the store has to comply with the letter as written, when in fact you should keep every response and work toward a resolution.
- The assumption that a shopper's email creates a production deadline, which it doesn't.
- The assumption that sanctions are guaranteed if the footage later disappears, which they aren't.
A tracking sheet keeps the stages apart (hypothetical entries).
- Requested, as in a letter delivered by certified mail on day 2, which means the store has notice of the request.
- Acknowledged, as in a claims office email on day 6 saying "received", which shows the letter arrived but doesn't prove the files were held.
- Preserved, as in the store saying on day 9 that "the clip was saved", which calls for asking which views and which minutes were saved.
- Produced, as in two files received after suit is filed, which calls for comparing them with the original request.
- Disputed, as in the store calling the 2:20 to 3:19 window overbroad, which calls for keeping the correspondence and seeking a ruling if needed.
Understand what Texas spoliation law requires
Brookshire Brothers v. Aldridge, the leading Texas case, arose from a grocery-store fall near a display table. [S5]
Question | What Brookshire Brothers says |
|---|---|
What were the facts? | The fall happened about 15 feet from a rotisserie-chicken area, and the store kept about eight minutes of video, from 5:01 to just before 5:09 p.m. |
Who decides? | The trial court, outside the jury's presence |
When does a duty to preserve arise? | When a party knows or reasonably should know there's a substantial chance a claim will be filed, and that evidence in its control will be material and relevant |
What counts as a breach? | Failing to use reasonable care to preserve the evidence, whether intentionally or negligently |
What remedy fits? | One that is proportionate, tied directly to the conduct, and not excessive |
When can the jury get a spoliation instruction? | After intentional spoliation plus a finding that a lesser remedy won't do, or in the rare negligent case that irreparably deprives the other side of any meaningful ability to present a claim or defense |
What happened in that case? | Giving the instruction was an abuse of discretion, and the court ordered a new trial |
The analysis is fact-specific: a missing recording isn't an automatic admission, and an adverse-inference instruction isn't the routine result of a retention problem.
- The actual record, which counsel should analyze, checking how later decisions have treated the case.
- A spoliation motion in the hypothetical, which would lay out what Camera 7 recorded, who controlled it, how the preservation request was handled and how losing 2:20 to 3:19 hurts the notice question.
- Overlapping evidence, since if Camera 12 or a witness covers the same minutes, the prejudice shrinks.
- The only evidence of duration, since if the lost hour was the only evidence of how long the spill sat there, you should say so plainly, without claiming to know what the footage would have shown.
- The shopper's own duties, which include keeping the photos, the texts and the social media posts about the fall, including the ones that look bad.
- Privacy and scope, which your lawyer can handle, while selective deletion starts a second fight that pulls attention away from the injury.
Obtain production through the proper procedure
Before a lawsuit, counsel can ask the store to cooperate and can consider presuit options.
Stage | What applies |
|---|---|
A Rule 202 presuit deposition | A court can order one only after finding that it may prevent a failure or delay of justice in an anticipated suit, or that its likely benefit outweighs the burden or expense, so it isn't open-ended discovery before deciding whether to sue [S6] |
After suit | The discovery rules, court orders, and proportionality limits govern, and federal court has its own procedures [S11] |
If the production comes up short, pin down exactly how, because a short technical exchange can clear up what looks like a dispute.
- Whether the camera existed that day, for example that Camera 12 may have been offline.
- Which clock the search used, the camera's clock or real time.
- Whether a file was left out for a technical reason, for example that it needed the vendor's player.
- If a judge gets involved, a clean record of requests and answers explains the relief being sought.
- Authentication before trial, where you figure out who can testify to where the recording came from and how the system works, or what other foundation will be used [S7].
- Working copies, which call for a list of every caption, zoom and speed change.
- Weighing clips, since a dramatic clip nobody can authenticate may be worth less than a plain one with solid support.
Why this work matters when choosing counsel
Aaron Herbert's official State Bar profile lists his board certification in Personal Injury Trial Law. [S1]
Ask the firm
- How would you preserve the recordings in my case?
- How would you check the timing and handle any gaps?
Why each matters, in the same order.
- A method you can follow and check is worth more than a promise that video will prove the store wrong.
- Clock problems and gaps decide what the video can actually prove.
Your part is simpler: pin down the exact spot, keep your original files, and tell the lawyer about any calls or emails with the store.
- Reach The Law Firm of Aaron A. Herbert or request a case evaluation with the date, the store address and the records you have, to contact the firm.
- About cameras, nothing; you don't need to know anything about the camera system.
- If anyone told you the footage might be deleted, mention that first.
- Related guides, such as The knowledge hub; notice and inspection evidence for what employees knew; discovery and corporate depositions for who can explain the system or the export.
- Preserve first, verify carefully and claim no more than the recording shows, as the rule of thumb.
What the shopper should expect from counsel
Three milestones are worth asking about separately, along with a few related questions.
Milestones and questions
- Did a preservation notice go out?
- Did the store acknowledge it?
- Did a request for the actual recordings follow?
- Which missing record could change how my claim is valued?
- Does formal discovery make sense yet?
- Can you get me the video right away?
- What should I get instead?
What to expect, in the same order.
- A yes or no, with the date.
- A separate answer from the first.
- Another separate step.
- A specific answer.
- A reasoned yes or no.
- No lawyer can get instant access to a private retailer's video just because someone was hurt.
- A prompt, documented effort through the proper procedures and a straight account of any gaps.
At a consultation with Aaron Herbert's firm, ask how the video would be used to test notice, beyond showing the fall; his verified board certification in Personal Injury Trial Law makes that a fair question. [S1]
- Strengthening the case, since the footage may show how long the hazard sat there.
- Revealing a weakness, which it's better to learn before deciding whether to settle.
- Showing that another source is needed, since any of these outcomes beats settling on an incomplete picture.
- The discovery article, as the next resource, which covers getting and authenticating the records.
Sources and legal context
How each source applies depends on your facts and current law, and none is a firm result.
- S1 State Bar of Texas profile for Aaron Alan Herbert, for the license date (November 6, 2002) and board certification in Personal Injury Trial Law.
- S5 Brookshire Brothers, Ltd. v. Aldridge, 438 S.W.3d 9 (Tex. 2014), majority opinion from the Supreme Court of Texas.
- S6 Texas Judicial Branch rules directory and the Texas Rules of Civil Procedure, as amended through October 1, 2026.
- S7 Texas Rules of Evidence, effective July 2, 2026.
- S11 Federal Rules of Civil Procedure and the federal rules directory.
- S15 Anderson-Brown v. Kroger Texas, L.P., No. 22-10985 (5th Cir. Mar. 17, 2023) (unpublished), opinion from the Fifth Circuit.
ABOUT THE ATTORNEY
Aaron A. Herbert
Founding Attorney
Board Certified in Personal Injury Trial Law
Aaron founded The Law Firm of Aaron A. Herbert in 2010 to focus on developing each client's case and seeking its maximum value. For over a decade, he has represented people seriously injured in major accidents and industrial catastrophes, pursuing trial verdicts and settlements while working to reduce the stress of litigation.
Education
- Texas A&M University · B.S., Criminal Justice, 1999
- University of Oklahoma College of Law · J.D., 2002; graduated in the top of his class
Trial experience & approach
Aaron earned numerous jury verdicts at boutique personal injury litigation firms. According to his biography, he spent a year as the top-earning litigation attorney at a firm that frequently appeared in verdict searches as having one of the highest numbers of trial wins in Texas. At another Dallas personal injury firm, he moved from managing pre-litigation attorney to managing litigation attorney over seven years as the firm grew into one of Dallas's largest personal injury firms.
His biography describes a reputation as one of America's most aggressive trial lawyers, with noteworthy recoveries from judges and juries and substantial pretrial settlements. Most of those settlements included confidentiality agreements requested by the defense. Aaron has said the recoveries were justified by the injuries and losses involved, which no amount of money could make someone choose to experience.
His approach combines passion, preparation, persistence and courtroom imagination. He believes a well-supported, engaged and motivated team working cooperatively helps deliver strong representation, with the goal of achieving the best possible result for every client.
Dallas roots, military service & publication
Born and raised in Dallas, Aaron enlisted in the United States Marine Corps after high school and later received an Honorable Discharge. He completed his university and law degrees after his military service and became a lifelong Sooners football fan in law school.
Publication: “Litigating Dog Bite Cases,” Texas Dog Law Seminar, Dallas, 2009.
Professional affiliations & recognition
Professional affiliations and recognition listed in Aaron’s biography:
- State Bar of Texas
- American Bar Association
- Association of Trial Lawyers of America (now American Association for Justice)
- Texas Trial Lawyers Association
- Dallas Trial Lawyers Association
- Dallas Bar Association
- Tarrant County Bar Association
- Million Dollar Advocates Forum
- The National Trial Lawyers – Top 100 Trial Lawyers
Trial experience & approach
Aaron earned numerous jury verdicts at boutique personal injury litigation firms. According to his biography, he spent a year as the top-earning litigation attorney at a firm that frequently appeared in verdict searches as having one of the highest numbers of trial wins in Texas. At another Dallas personal injury firm, he moved from managing pre-litigation attorney to managing litigation attorney over seven years as the firm grew into one of Dallas's largest personal injury firms.
His biography describes a reputation as one of America's most aggressive trial lawyers, with noteworthy recoveries from judges and juries and substantial pretrial settlements. Most of those settlements included confidentiality agreements requested by the defense. Aaron has said the recoveries were justified by the injuries and losses involved, which no amount of money could make someone choose to experience.
His approach combines passion, preparation, persistence and courtroom imagination. He believes a well-supported, engaged and motivated team working cooperatively helps deliver strong representation, with the goal of achieving the best possible result for every client.
Dallas roots, military service & publication
Born and raised in Dallas, Aaron enlisted in the United States Marine Corps after high school and later received an Honorable Discharge. He completed his university and law degrees after his military service and became a lifelong Sooners football fan in law school.
Publication: “Litigating Dog Bite Cases,” Texas Dog Law Seminar, Dallas, 2009.
Professional affiliations & recognition
Professional affiliations and recognition listed in Aaron’s biography:
- State Bar of Texas
- American Bar Association
- Association of Trial Lawyers of America (now American Association for Justice)
- Texas Trial Lawyers Association
- Dallas Trial Lawyers Association
- Dallas Bar Association
- Tarrant County Bar Association
- Million Dollar Advocates Forum
- The National Trial Lawyers – Top 100 Trial Lawyers
