The certified lawyer is not automatically the person who handles your file. TBLS certification belongs to one individual, and a firm may assign daily work to associates, paralegals and case managers under a lawyer's supervision. Before you sign, ask which lawyer is responsible for your case, what the certified lawyer will personally do, and who makes the major decisions.
The distinction between a certified individual and a firm
The Texas Board of Legal Specialization certifies one lawyer at a time, in one field. So when a firm's website says its founding lawyer is Board Certified in Personal Injury Trial Law, that sentence is about him. Not about the associate down the hall. Not the case manager, not the paralegal, and not the firm as a business. That doesn't make the uncertified lawyer a weak one. Plenty of them are very good, and it's often fine for them to do a big share of the work. What you want is a firm that will tell you plainly which lawyer holds the credential, who else will touch your file, and who owns the big decisions. If you want the detail on what board certification in personal injury trial law actually requires, start there. TBLS certification standards, Part I, section I.D.
A lawyer's name and verdicts may bring you to a firm, but they do not explain who will handle your case. For example, you might sign the contract and spend the next three weeks hearing only from a case manager whose name was not on the website. That arrangement is not necessarily a problem: firms depend on delegation. You still need to know which lawyer is responsible and how to reach that person when it matters. A headshot, biography or framed certificate does not establish that the pictured lawyer has reviewed your file. Ask how the firm staffs a claim like yours, who supervises it and who makes the important decisions. An answer that stops at “our team handles it” leaves those questions unresolved.
Aaron A. Herbert's TBLS certification, as the firm's site describes it, belongs to Aaron personally. If you're thinking about hiring the firm, ask what part Aaron expects to play in your matter. The honest answer depends on the firm's actual capacity, how big the case looks, and what changes later. This article lays out good questions to put to any firm. It isn't a promise that Aaron personally does a particular task in every case.
Who performs the initial case evaluation
On the first call, the firm asks your name and what happened. It also asks whether your injuries need attention today, evidence may disappear or a deadline is near. The person asking may be excellent at the job. They are still not giving you a legal opinion, and you shouldn't hear one. Whether the firm takes the case, and on what terms, is a lawyer's decision, or at the very least one a lawyer supervises. Before the call ends, ask whether a lawyer will review your paperwork before the firm decides, who is watching the deadlines and when you will receive something in writing. That written response could be an engagement agreement or a letter declining the case.
Intake scripts are built for the typical case. Yours might not be typical. Maybe a government vehicle was involved. Maybe a defective product, or a child, or a death. Maybe there's an employer in the picture or a defendant in another state. Any one of those can mean the file needs to get to a lawyer fast, and a script won't catch it unless you have a way to say so. Tell the firm about pending offers. Tell them about written claim denials, surveillance notices, anything that could be destroyed. They should tell you, in turn, whether the first screening is just preliminary and what other records they need. One more thing. Until you're actually represented, don't assume any lawyer is watching your limitations period for you.
Once you've signed, a responsible lawyer should lay out an investigation plan. The team may order records, track down witnesses, or get in touch with insurers. The lawyer decides which liability theories and which defendants are worth chasing, and when to bring in specialized help. How much gets delegated varies from firm to firm. What you can fairly expect is one clear point of contact, plus a way to get a legal question in front of an attorney who knows your file.
Lawyers, paralegals, case managers, and experts do different work
Paralegals and case managers are the ones who make a case move. They're organizing medical records, chasing providers who haven't sent anything, tracking bills, coordinating document requests, keeping you posted on the routine stuff. A private investigator might find a witness or photograph the scene. A specialist might work through the engineering, or the medicine, or the economics, or the vocational questions. None of that is optional in a serious case. But all of it has to connect back to a lawyer's read on the legal issues, or it's just activity.
Some questions belong in a conversation with an attorney. Whether to sue. What a settlement really means for the value of your claim. How comparative responsibility cuts into it. Whether a motion puts the case at serious risk. Certification doesn't require the certified lawyer to send every records request, but delegated work still needs real supervision. Hearing from staff every week tells you nothing about whether counsel watched the decisive video or read the proposed release. If a question needs an attorney's answer, ask for a conversation with the responsible lawyer. And find out which developments the firm routes to counsel automatically. Texas Disciplinary Rule 5.03.
Look, nobody expects the lawyer to sit at the fax machine sending records requests, or to call the imaging center to book your appointment. That was never the point. The point is that whoever does a task is trained for it, and that the legal questions, the ones that change the outcome, are supervised by an attorney. A decent firm can explain how that works in its office without telling you its strategy and without pretending that every file gets the same treatment. They don't. They can't.

Who decides what evidence must be preserved
Evidence may need attention before the firm has assembled a file. A case manager can gather your photographs and identify people who saw what happened. That is useful work, but a lawyer must decide which evidence to pursue. Which sources does your case call for? The store's camera footage? The truck's electronic data? Driver records, a broken part, maintenance records or an employer's incident report may also matter. The choice depends on the facts and on identifying where the evidence may be held. Ask how the team will identify those sources. A request naming a particular camera and time window will usually be more useful than a general demand for “all evidence.”
A preservation letter needs follow-through. Who writes the preservation letter? Who signs it? Who calls when nothing shows up, and what happens when the other side says it never had the footage or the system wrote over it? The signed letter alone cannot save that video. Someone still has to identify the cameras and time window, find the person or business holding the footage, learn the retention cycle and ask about backups. After filing suit, counsel can use discovery and seek help from the judge when needed. The whole way through, there should be a paper trail. What was asked for. When. What came back.
Some evidence is already in your hands. Keep your photos in their original format. Keep the texts, the damaged items, the receipts, and the treatment records. Tell the firm about social media posts or recording devices, including the ones that don't help you. And ask a lawyer before you repair, throw out, or test anything the other side may want to inspect. Your legal team should spell these responsibilities out in plain English instead of leaving you to work them out from a form letter.
Who works with the medical evidence
Staff can obtain medical records and arrange them in a timeline. Evaluating what those records mean for your claim requires legal judgment and sometimes expert input. A report may establish that you have an injury without explaining who caused it. Your chart may contain a history that differs from your account, a pre-existing condition or an uncertain prognosis. A lawyer should review those problems, identify the additional proof needed and explain the remaining uncertainty to you. The timeline is a useful starting point for that work. It should not become the basis for a theory of causation without someone with legal training checking the underlying records and the summary.
If you expect to need more treatment, ask who is reviewing the evidence for those future costs. The plan must rest on medical evidence and assumptions that can withstand cross-examination. A claim for lost earning capacity also involves employment records, tax returns and vocational and economic information. The firm must address the disputes over the reasonable value of past medical bills and repayment from the recovery. Who at the firm catches those issues? Which experts might they hire? Who approves the cost? The answers should reflect the needs of your case. Identifying those needs does not amount to a promise to retain every available specialist.
Don't go get treatment just to build a claim. Medical decisions belong to you and your doctors. The legal team's job is to get accurate records, tell you what information it needs, and account for your treatment and your finances when it sizes up a settlement. If a provider recommends a major change in your care, tell the firm right away. The damages picture and your future needs may have just changed.
Who negotiates and who decides whether to accept an offer
Negotiation may involve a lawyer writing the demand, speaking with the adjuster or taking part in mediation. The lawyer may also delegate some of that work and supervise it. Either can work. What you need to know, whichever way it's done, is who said each number, whether it's an opening position or a final proposal, and what comes out of the gross figure for costs and repayment claims before a dollar reaches you. Will an attorney go over a significant offer with you personally? Will you get an estimate of the net? Ask both. And make the estimate say which assumptions are still unsettled.
Your lawyer advises. You decide whether to settle. Not a courtesy, a rule. Texas Disciplinary Rule 1.02(a)(2). It's a hard decision, because pressing on costs money and time and nobody can promise the outcome. So what should the advice look like? The offer, set next to the evidence you expect to have and the realistic road ahead. The deadline, if there is one. What the release actually does once you sign it. Whether other defendants or other claims are still in play. What the advice should never be is a bare “take it” or “reject it.” Not with this much riding on it.
Ask the firm how it records your authority to settle and how it handles a disagreement about strategy. Discuss the choices involved before a disagreement becomes urgent. You and your lawyer may view delay, public testimony, financial pressure or the risks of trial differently. The advice should account for your circumstances and the lawyer's judgment, rather than how a result would make the firm look. As you learn more about the case, your goals may change. Tell your lawyer when that happens so the recommendation can be considered again in light of what now matters to you.
Who signs pleadings, takes depositions, and appears in court
The lawyer who signs a pleading or stands up at a hearing answers for it, under the rules and the court's orders. Several lawyers may work on a case, with assignments changing as litigation proceeds. Ask who is expected to take the driver's deposition and who will question the store manager, corporate representative or doctor when those witnesses are involved. Find out who will prepare you for your own deposition and argue the important motions. The firm should identify the likely assignments and explain how it adjusts them when schedules conflict or the case becomes more difficult than expected.
A lawyer's courtroom experience is useful when it relates to the proof your case requires. A first-chair trial record tells you that the lawyer has led a case at trial. It does not establish that the lawyer knows your witnesses or can attend a trial whose date has not yet been set. Ask when the firm expects to select trial counsel and how it makes that choice. Find out whether another lawyer, including outside counsel, may participate. If a referring lawyer or co-counsel is involved, ask how the lawyers divide their responsibilities and coordinate the advice you receive.
A lawyer who joins shortly before trial may be able to master a well-prepared file; that depends on both the lawyer and the file. Ask about the preparation already done: who attended the key depositions, shaped the expert disclosures, identified the defense's strongest evidence and planned how to authenticate the exhibits? Those answers show how trial preparation has been handled. A promise that a prominent lawyer will “step in” at the end does not answer them.
What to expect from supervision and quality control
How does the firm track deadlines? How are tasks assigned, and how does an attorney end up actually reading the documents that matter? Ask, because a file can generate a great deal of staff activity while nobody reviews the strategy. Certain things should hit a lawyer's desk every single time. A limitations period about to run. A witness nobody knew about. A liability denial. A serious change in your medical condition, a material expert opinion, a significant offer, a ruling that went against you. The firm doesn't owe you a tour of its workflow. It owes you a straight answer about how things get escalated and who is accountable when they are.
Supervision also includes responding to mistakes. If a records request went unanswered or a call was not returned, ask who will investigate and correct the problem. You should know whom to contact when the usual channel goes quiet. A certified lawyer's name on the letterhead does not prevent administrative errors. Look for an explanation of how a problem was addressed and whether it received timely legal review, rather than a claim that the office never misses anything.
Read what the firm sends you, including the factual summaries. If the demand letter names the wrong employer or puts events in the wrong order, tell the firm as soon as you see the mistake. You may remember something your lawyer has not yet learned. Correcting the account gives counsel the facts needed to assess the claim; deciding their legal significance is the lawyer's job. Your contribution helps keep the record accurate without making you responsible for legal strategy.
Fees, expenses, and work outside the original scope
Read the entire engagement agreement before signing it. Check how the contingent fee is calculated and whether the percentage increases after filing suit or on appeal. Ask how the firm handles litigation expenses and who pays them if there is no recovery. If you are concerned about a separate charge for a phone call or other work, ask the firm to explain when such a charge would apply. The agreement should identify the client, describe the scope of representation and disclose any referral or joint-counsel arrangement. A website's statement of “No fee unless you recover” does not explain expenses, liens or what happens if the representation ends. Texas Disciplinary Rule 1.04(d)–(g).
A new defendant, an appeal, a separate insurance dispute or a family member's related claim can raise a question about the engagement's scope. Ask whether that work is included before assuming the firm will handle it. One injury may lead to several legal proceedings, and counsel should explain which ones the agreement covers. If the firm represents several family members, possible conflicts and the division of a limited recovery may require separate attention. Your lawyer should explain when additional work needs your authorization and when you may need a different lawyer for it.
A certification doesn't settle any of this. It doesn't set the fee and it doesn't answer the questions above. Compare the agreements themselves: what services are on offer, and whether the firm can actually fund and manage the work your case is going to need. A lower percentage isn't automatically the better deal. A higher one doesn't prove greater skill. Get real answers, and take the time to understand them before you sign anything.
If responsibility changes during the case
A staffing change can happen because a lawyer leaves the firm, becomes unavailable, encounters a conflict or brings in a colleague with relevant expertise. New facts can also make a case more or less complicated. When a change materially affects the staffing of your case, you should be told who is now responsible so you can assess whether the arrangement still works for you. Ask whether the departing lawyer handed over the file, who has reviewed the record since and who is covering the deadlines already on the calendar.
Tell the firm early if you cannot reach your lawyer, an update has not arrived, a settlement question went unanswered or you do not know where the claim stands. Naming the particular problem gives the firm a chance to address it. You generally have the right to choose your representation. Changing lawyers during litigation, however, raises questions about fees, liens, scheduling and the court that require individual advice. Keep track of important deadlines while looking for another lawyer; frustration with the current firm is no reason to let one pass. Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 10.
A lawyer arriving just before mediation or trial needs more than the file. Before mediation, the lawyer advising you on settlement should know your goals and the evidence on both sides. Before trial, counsel should know the earlier sworn testimony and the commitments made in discovery. If the lawyer changes at either point, ask to meet and go through the immediate plan together. That conversation lets you discuss the work ahead. Sending the documents alone does not show that the incoming lawyer understands the case or is ready to take responsibility for it.
Ten questions that reveal the staffing plan
- Who is the attorney primarily responsible for my case?
- What specific role will the board-certified attorney have?
- Who will assess legal deadlines and send preservation requests?
- Which team member will request and review medical records?
- Who decides whether to hire an expert and how are those expenses approved?
- Who will take significant depositions and argue motions?
- Who reviews offers with me, including a projected net recovery?
- Who would be trial counsel if the case is set for trial?
- How do I reach an attorney about an urgent issue?
- How will you notify me if the staffing or scope changes?
Write down the firm's answers about who is responsible today, what work comes next and how it will decide on staffing if circumstances change. Those answers can be concrete even though the firm cannot promise who will do every task two years from now. Keep them with the engagement agreement and compare them with later updates. You're not micromanaging a legal team. You're trying to understand the relationship you're about to enter.
Frequently asked questions
Can an associate try my case? An associate may have a significant role at trial. The assignment depends on the lawyer's experience, the firm's staffing, the court's schedule and what you agreed to. Ask who is expected to lead, when that decision will be made and whether another lawyer may participate. A biography on the website describes a lawyer; it does not answer those questions about your case.
What if my engagement letter names only the firm? Common. A professional corporation can be the party to the contract while several attorneys do the actual work. So ask for a name. Which lawyer is responsible for my file? Who supervises the work? Who reviews the big decisions? Write that person's contact information down somewhere you'll find it, and if the assignments change, ask for an update.
How can I tell whether a lawyer is reviewing my matter? At a decision point, ask the responsible lawyer about the theory of liability, the most important evidence still missing, the main defense and the next investigative step. Those are specific subjects you can discuss together. If an offer arrives, ask why the lawyer recommends accepting or rejecting it and what your net recovery would be. The explanation helps you understand the assessment behind the advice. Automated status emails can report work on the file without showing whether an attorney has reviewed these questions.
What if my attorney is unavailable when something urgent happens? Before an urgent problem arises, find out how the office handles it when your lead lawyer is in trial or out of town. When reporting the problem, send the relevant document and state the deadline. If a legal right is about to expire and the firm cannot give you a timely response, seek independent advice immediately. Keep a record of each attempt to contact the firm.
This article provides general information, not legal advice for a specific case or a promise about any particular staffing arrangement. Ask the firm to confirm the scope and responsible attorney for your matter.
ABOUT THE ATTORNEY
Aaron A. Herbert
Founding Attorney
Board Certified in Personal Injury Trial Law
Aaron founded The Law Firm of Aaron A. Herbert in 2010 to focus on developing each client's case and seeking its maximum value. For over a decade, he has represented people seriously injured in major accidents and industrial catastrophes, pursuing trial verdicts and settlements while working to reduce the stress of litigation.
Education
- Texas A&M University · B.S., Criminal Justice, 1999
- University of Oklahoma College of Law · J.D., 2002; graduated in the top of his class
Trial experience & approach
Aaron earned numerous jury verdicts at boutique personal injury litigation firms. According to his biography, he spent a year as the top-earning litigation attorney at a firm that frequently appeared in verdict searches as having one of the highest numbers of trial wins in Texas. At another Dallas personal injury firm, he moved from managing pre-litigation attorney to managing litigation attorney over seven years as the firm grew into one of Dallas's largest personal injury firms.
His biography describes a reputation as one of America's most aggressive trial lawyers, with noteworthy recoveries from judges and juries and substantial pretrial settlements. Most of those settlements included confidentiality agreements requested by the defense. Aaron has said the recoveries were justified by the injuries and losses involved, which no amount of money could make someone choose to experience.
His approach combines passion, preparation, persistence and courtroom imagination. He believes a well-supported, engaged and motivated team working cooperatively helps deliver strong representation, with the goal of achieving the best possible result for every client.
Dallas roots, military service & publication
Born and raised in Dallas, Aaron enlisted in the United States Marine Corps after high school and later received an Honorable Discharge. He completed his university and law degrees after his military service and became a lifelong Sooners football fan in law school.
Publication: “Litigating Dog Bite Cases,” Texas Dog Law Seminar, Dallas, 2009.
Professional affiliations & recognition
Professional affiliations and recognition listed in Aaron’s biography:
- State Bar of Texas
- American Bar Association
- Association of Trial Lawyers of America (now American Association for Justice)
- Texas Trial Lawyers Association
- Dallas Trial Lawyers Association
- Dallas Bar Association
- Tarrant County Bar Association
- Million Dollar Advocates Forum
- The National Trial Lawyers – Top 100 Trial Lawyers
Trial experience & approach
Aaron earned numerous jury verdicts at boutique personal injury litigation firms. According to his biography, he spent a year as the top-earning litigation attorney at a firm that frequently appeared in verdict searches as having one of the highest numbers of trial wins in Texas. At another Dallas personal injury firm, he moved from managing pre-litigation attorney to managing litigation attorney over seven years as the firm grew into one of Dallas's largest personal injury firms.
His biography describes a reputation as one of America's most aggressive trial lawyers, with noteworthy recoveries from judges and juries and substantial pretrial settlements. Most of those settlements included confidentiality agreements requested by the defense. Aaron has said the recoveries were justified by the injuries and losses involved, which no amount of money could make someone choose to experience.
His approach combines passion, preparation, persistence and courtroom imagination. He believes a well-supported, engaged and motivated team working cooperatively helps deliver strong representation, with the goal of achieving the best possible result for every client.
Dallas roots, military service & publication
Born and raised in Dallas, Aaron enlisted in the United States Marine Corps after high school and later received an Honorable Discharge. He completed his university and law degrees after his military service and became a lifelong Sooners football fan in law school.
Publication: “Litigating Dog Bite Cases,” Texas Dog Law Seminar, Dallas, 2009.
Professional affiliations & recognition
Professional affiliations and recognition listed in Aaron’s biography:
- State Bar of Texas
- American Bar Association
- Association of Trial Lawyers of America (now American Association for Justice)
- Texas Trial Lawyers Association
- Dallas Trial Lawyers Association
- Dallas Bar Association
- Tarrant County Bar Association
- Million Dollar Advocates Forum
- The National Trial Lawyers – Top 100 Trial Lawyers
