Skip to content
Board Certified in Personal Injury Trial Law - Texas Board of Legal Specialization
 214-200-4878
The Law Firm Of Aaron A. Herbert, P.C. Logo
24/7 Free Consultation

No Fees or Expenses Unless You Recover
214-200-4878
  • About
    • Attorneys
      • Aaron A Herbert
      • Marissa Maggio
      • Jordan Terashima
    • Testimonials
    • Results
  • Areas We Serve
    • Dallas County
      • Carrollton
      • Cedar Hill
      • Dallas
        • Apartment Injuries
        • Bicycle Accidents
        • Birth Injuries
        • Brain Injuries
        • Dog Bites
      • Garland
        • Boat Accidents
        • Car Accidents
        • DUI Accidents
        • Dog Bites
        • Slip & Fall Accidents
      • Highland Park
      • Irving
        • Bicycle Accidents
        • Car Accidents
        • Construction Site Accidents
        • Truck Accidents
        • Uber & Lyft Rideshare Accidents
      • Mesquite
        • Burn Injuries
        • Car Accidents
        • Dog Bites
        • Pedestrian Accidents
        • Truck Accidents
      • Richardson
        • Brain Injuries
        • Car Accidents
        • Daycare Abuse & Injuries
        • Drunk Driving Accidents
        • Spinal Cord Injuries
    • Tarrant County
      • Fort Worth
        • Personal Injury
        • Car Accident
        • Semi Truck Accident
        • Slip and Fall
        • Construction Accidents
        • Motorcycle Accident
        • View All +
      • Arlington
      • Colleyville
      • Mansfield
      • North Richland Hills
      • Richland Hills
      • Southlake
    • Collin County
      • Allen
        • Bicycle Accidents
        • Car Accidents
        • Child Injuries
        • Fatal Accidents
      • Frisco
        • Car Accidents
        • Dog Bites
        • Motorcycle Accidents
        • Truck Accidents
        • Uninsured & Underinsured Driver Accidents
      • McKinney
        • Car Accidents
        • Distracted Driving Accidents
        • DUI Accidents
        • Fatal Accidents
      • Murphy
      • Plano
        • Brain Injuries
        • Car Accidents
        • Crash Accident Reports
        • Motorcycle Accidents
        • Negligent Security
        • Texting & Driving Accidents
        • Truck Accidents
        • Wrongful Death
      • Wylie
      • Prosper
    • Comal County
      • New Braunfels
    • Denton County
      • Denton
        • Bicycle Accidents
        • Brain Injuries
        • Distracted Driving Accidents
        • Uber & Lyft Rideshare Accidents
      • Flower Mound
      • Hickory Creek
      • Providence Village
      • Roanoke
    • Parker County
      • Parker
      • Reno
    • Grand Prairie
      • Bicycle Accidents
      • Car Accidents
      • Slip & Fall Accidents
      • Truck Accidents
    • Houston
      • Personal Injury
      • Houston Car Accident Lawyer
    • San Antonio
      • Personal Injury
      • Slip and Fall
      • Truck Accidents
      • Wrongful Death
      • Workplace Injuries
      • Premises Liability
      • Traumatic Brain Injury
  • Practice Areas
    • Personal Injury
    • Car Accidents
    • Truck Accidents
    • Motorcycle Accidents
    • Bicycle Accidents
    • Pedestrian Accidents
    • Slip and Fall
    • Brain Injury
    • Dog Bites
    • Wrongful Death
    • View All +
  • Blog
  • Contact
Home / Personal Injury Blog / Do Insurance Companies Track Personal Injury Lawyers’ Trial Records?

Do Insurance Companies Track Personal Injury Lawyers’ Trial Records?

Do insurance companies and Defense Firms keep records on plaintiffs’ attorneys achievements? Yes — and the records are now a formal, productized part of the insurance claims industry, not just adjuster folklore. But the way it works is different from…

September 16, 2026
Aaron A. Herbert

Written by Aaron A. HerbertTexas Bar #24036761 · Board Certified in Personal Injury Trial Law by the Texas Board of Legal Specialization since 2008.
The Law Firm of Aaron A. Herbert, P.C. · Dallas, Texas

No fee unless we win. You pay no fees or expenses unless you recover. Request a free case review

Desk with stacked claim folders and a laptop showing a blurred data spreadsheet, with the Dallas skyline outside.

Home  >  Personal Injury Blog  >  Do Insurance Companies Track Personal Injury Lawyers’ Trial Records?

Wednesday, September 16, 2026 | By Aaron A. Herbert
Do Insurance Companies Track Personal Injury Lawyers’ Trial Records?

Do insurance companies and Defense Firms keep records on plaintiffs’ attorneys achievements?

Yes — and the records are now a formal, productized part of the insurance claims industry, not just adjuster folklore. But the way it works is different from how it’s usually described in plaintiff-firm marketing, and that distinction matters strategically.

Here’s what the evidence actually supports, in descending order of documentation quality.

1. Purpose-built attorney scoring is a real product carriers buy

This is the strongest, least-speculative evidence. CLARA Analytics sells a litigation module that looks at attorney outcomes on prior claims and scores those attorneys on factors including performance and cost. Gen Re — a Berkshire reinsurer, writing to its carrier clients — describes it plainly: it offers detailed scorecards for both plaintiff and defense counsel using historical data, benchmarks defense counsel against peers, and includes head-to-head matchup analysis showing whether the assigned defense attorney has previously faced the opposing plaintiff’s counsel.

Adjusters are prompted to identify cases where their defense attorney is up against a high-scoring plaintiff’s attorney, raising the risk of an expensive outcome, and to use score explanations to decide whether to replace counsel or push for settlement. It ships as a pre-built Guidewire integration, meaning the score can sit inside the core claims system an adjuster works in all day.

The same vendor also maps relationships between plaintiff attorneys, medical providers, and claimants across millions of claims to flag SIU referrals — i.e., attorney-provider network analysis, not just win rates.

Person reviewing an attorney performance scorecard on a claims software screen.

2. Claims valuations is subtler and arguably worse for claimants

Each carrier “tunes” the program to its own settlement history and regions, which drives the dollar range it produces. If a firm consistently settles cheaply, those settlements feed the tuning data. The attorney effect is real but largely emergent — baked into the comparables — rather than a discrete “reputation” field.

3. Public docket and verdict analytics

Lex Machina produces data on law firms and individual attorneys, showing the most active litigation firms and their track records, plus timing distributions for summary judgment, trial, and termination — drawn from PACER and state systems and updated daily. Bloomberg Law offers attorney and law firm analytics covering over 100,000 lawyers and nearly 800 firms. Trellis does the same for state trial courts, which is where nearly all PI lives.

Settlement databases matter more than verdict databases here. CaseMetrix was built on the premise that 95%+ of cases settle and no one — plaintiff bar, defense bar, or carriers — had a comprehensive guide to those values, and it explicitly treats insurance companies, adjusters, and plaintiff and defense attorneys as searchable variables alongside injury and venue. Plaintiff attorneys, defense attorneys, and insurance carriers use it.

4. Defense law firms: formalized, but qualitative

Defense firm evaluation of opposing counsel is doctrine, not gossip. A published med-mal case evaluation guide instructs defense counsel to identify plaintiff’s counsel, investigate opposing counsel’s reputation, experience, and willingness to try or settle cases, and evaluate what impact the quality of opposing counsel will have on the outcome.

CLM — the claims-and-litigation-management trade body — runs practitioner guidance on evaluating opposing counsel that tells adjusters to look up plaintiff counsel’s bar date, assess negotiation style and the artfulness of the complaint and discovery, and canvass colleagues handling claims in the same jurisdiction. Note the tell: it treats defense counsel’s prior experience with that specific plaintiff’s attorney as one of the most significant advantages defense counsel brings to a claim.

Lawyer reviewing an opposing counsel profile and strategy notes at a desk.

5. Industry-level surveillance of the plaintiff bar

Beyond reviewing individual files, X Ante tracks nearly all law-firm television advertising in mass tort and product liability, plus Google, Facebook, and other online legal advertising, and sells it to insurers, pharma, and defense firms. Triple-I and APCIA maintain the “legal system abuse” research program, tracking $2.5 billion in legal-services ad spend across 26.9 million ads.

The analytical caveats

  • Selection bias can cut both ways. A firm with a 90% trial win rate may just be trying only its best cases. A firm that tries a lot and loses some may be more feared by defense law firms and Insurance carriers, and correctly so.
  • case outcomes in the Court Docket data is thin and weak where PI results actually reside. Federal PACER coverage is excellent; county-level state court coverage is uneven. A high-volume soft-tissue practice can be nearly invisible in Lex Machina.
  • Confidential negotiated settlements between litigants are the missing 95%.
  • Contributory databases (CLARA’s closed-claim pool, CaseMetrix’s attorney network) exist precisely because the public record can’t answer the question.
  • The case outcome scoring predicts behavior, not necessarily quality. The operative variable is “will this lawyer actually file, work up, prepare and try this case,” which is a filing-rate and cycle-time question more than a verdict question.

Regulatory and discovery angles worth knowing

The Allstate NAIC multistate exam produced a $10 million agreement with 45 states after examiners found inconsistencies in Allstate’s oversight of Colossus software, requiring, among other things, that adjusters not be required to settle based solely on the Colossus value, that incentives tied to Colossus amounts be eliminated, and that claimants be notified when the software is used. Consumer advocates argued the exam was too narrow, covering only one company using only one system.

The practical upshot for a PI practitioner: the existence of attorney scoring is a discovery and bad-faith fact pattern, not just a marketing grievance. Claim file notes, the valuation report and range, tuning documentation, and any counsel scorecard output are all things to request — and the presence of a low offer paired with an internal “low litigation risk” attorney score is exactly the kind of evidence that supports a failure-to-evaluate theory.

Conference table with stacked binders and file boxes, a magnifying glass on a document and a laptop showing a blurred chart.

Aaron A. Herbert

ABOUT THE ATTORNEY

Aaron A. Herbert

Founding Attorney

Board Certified in Personal Injury Trial Law

Texas Board of Legal Specialization · Since 2008

Licensed in Texas since 2002

Aaron founded The Law Firm of Aaron A. Herbert in 2010 to focus on developing each client's case and seeking its maximum value. For over a decade, he has represented people seriously injured in major accidents and industrial catastrophes, pursuing trial verdicts and settlements while working to reduce the stress of litigation.

Education

  • Texas A&M University · B.S., Criminal Justice, 1999
  • University of Oklahoma College of Law · J.D., 2002; graduated in the top of his class
Read Aaron's full biographyVerify Board Certification with TBLS
Trial experience & approach

Aaron earned numerous jury verdicts at boutique personal injury litigation firms. According to his biography, he spent a year as the top-earning litigation attorney at a firm that frequently appeared in verdict searches as having one of the highest numbers of trial wins in Texas. At another Dallas personal injury firm, he moved from managing pre-litigation attorney to managing litigation attorney over seven years as the firm grew into one of Dallas's largest personal injury firms.

His biography describes a reputation as one of America's most aggressive trial lawyers, with noteworthy recoveries from judges and juries and substantial pretrial settlements. Most of those settlements included confidentiality agreements requested by the defense. Aaron has said the recoveries were justified by the injuries and losses involved, which no amount of money could make someone choose to experience.

His approach combines passion, preparation, persistence and courtroom imagination. He believes a well-supported, engaged and motivated team working cooperatively helps deliver strong representation, with the goal of achieving the best possible result for every client.

Dallas roots, military service & publication

Born and raised in Dallas, Aaron enlisted in the United States Marine Corps after high school and later received an Honorable Discharge. He completed his university and law degrees after his military service and became a lifelong Sooners football fan in law school.

Publication: “Litigating Dog Bite Cases,” Texas Dog Law Seminar, Dallas, 2009.

Professional affiliations & recognition

Professional affiliations and recognition listed in Aaron’s biography:

  • State Bar of Texas
  • American Bar Association
  • Association of Trial Lawyers of America (now American Association for Justice)
  • Texas Trial Lawyers Association
  • Dallas Trial Lawyers Association
  • Dallas Bar Association
  • Tarrant County Bar Association
  • Million Dollar Advocates Forum
  • The National Trial Lawyers – Top 100 Trial Lawyers

Trial experience & approach

Aaron earned numerous jury verdicts at boutique personal injury litigation firms. According to his biography, he spent a year as the top-earning litigation attorney at a firm that frequently appeared in verdict searches as having one of the highest numbers of trial wins in Texas. At another Dallas personal injury firm, he moved from managing pre-litigation attorney to managing litigation attorney over seven years as the firm grew into one of Dallas's largest personal injury firms.

His biography describes a reputation as one of America's most aggressive trial lawyers, with noteworthy recoveries from judges and juries and substantial pretrial settlements. Most of those settlements included confidentiality agreements requested by the defense. Aaron has said the recoveries were justified by the injuries and losses involved, which no amount of money could make someone choose to experience.

His approach combines passion, preparation, persistence and courtroom imagination. He believes a well-supported, engaged and motivated team working cooperatively helps deliver strong representation, with the goal of achieving the best possible result for every client.

Dallas roots, military service & publication

Born and raised in Dallas, Aaron enlisted in the United States Marine Corps after high school and later received an Honorable Discharge. He completed his university and law degrees after his military service and became a lifelong Sooners football fan in law school.

Publication: “Litigating Dog Bite Cases,” Texas Dog Law Seminar, Dallas, 2009.

Professional affiliations & recognition

Professional affiliations and recognition listed in Aaron’s biography:

  • State Bar of Texas
  • American Bar Association
  • Association of Trial Lawyers of America (now American Association for Justice)
  • Texas Trial Lawyers Association
  • Dallas Trial Lawyers Association
  • Dallas Bar Association
  • Tarrant County Bar Association
  • Million Dollar Advocates Forum
  • The National Trial Lawyers – Top 100 Trial Lawyers

Tell Us About Your Case

No fee unless we win

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Aaron Herbert

Our Practice Areas

Personal injury representation.
Explore how we can help.

  • Car Accidents
  • Wrongful Death
  • Motorcycle Accidents
  • Truck Accidents
  • Work Injury
  • Bicycle Accidents
  • Slip & Falls
  • Traumatic Brain Injury
Here when you need answers.

Learn about your options after an injury.

Locations
  • Dallas
  • Fort Worth
Testimonials
I am satisfied
I am satisfied. My experience was good, the staff was good and I appreciate you all working on my case.

F.M.


I understood the entire process and best course of action
Attorney Aaron Herbert and his staff were very patient during the whole process and able to deal with healthcare providers. In addition they went out of their way to make sure I understood the entire process and best course of...
Read More
Attorney Aaron Herbert and his staff were very patient during the whole process and able to deal with healthcare providers. In addition they went out of their way to make sure I understood the entire process and best course of action.

L.F.


I will refer Aaron’s law firm to all the people I know
VERY satisfied with what Aaron’s law firm has done for me and my family. I will refer Aaron’s law firm to all the people I know personally and professionally.

A.A.


I just want to give a big thanks to this law firm
I was very satisfied with the law firm staff. They were very nice & respectful. They kept in contact with me about my case and fought hard for my case. My overall experience with this firm has been wonderful. They...
Read More
I was very satisfied with the law firm staff. They were very nice & respectful. They kept in contact with me about my case and fought hard for my case. My overall experience with this firm has been wonderful. They got me an amount greater than I expected. I just want to give a big thanks to this law firm , once again guys thank you so much!

M.C.


We are very pleased with our payout
Our experience was very good. The staff was very helpful and informative with any questions and walked us through the entire process. We are very pleased with our payout.

D.B.


Happy with my settlement
Happy with my settlement!

A.P.


He has a lifetime referral from me
Mr. Herbert is a lawyer with outstanding skills in being a trustworthy lawyer and as a person. I have very good confidence in any future situations with life and he will be the first person I call. He handled 2...
Read More
Mr. Herbert is a lawyer with outstanding skills in being a trustworthy lawyer and as a person. I have very good confidence in any future situations with life and he will be the first person I call. He handled 2 cases for me back to back and everything went smoothly as planned. He will fight for you and put in countless hours. He has a lifetime referral from me.

C.N.


The law firm staff and attorneys were very nice
The law firm staff and attorneys were very nice, helpful, understanding and very concerned about my case and any questions I had. I will tell family and friends that this law firm gets results!

R.H.


Great experience with this firm, very prompt service
Great experience with this firm, very prompt service.

K.M.


I highly recommend this law firm
Second time having Attorney Herbert represent me in an auto accident. I am very satisfied with his service and the firm staff was extremely professional. I highly recommend this law firm.

C.S.


   
                               
The Law Firm Of Aaron A. Herbert, P.C. Logo
214-200-4878FREE CONSULTATION

Dallas Office

8330 Lyndon B Johnson Fwy #700,
Dallas, Texas 75243
(214) 200-4878

Fort Worth Office

4200 South Fwy #412,
Fort Worth, Texas 76115
(817) 500-4878

Take the first step toward the compensation you deserve.

No fee unless we win.

"*" indicates required fields

By providing your mobile number, you agree to receive text messages from The Law Firm of Aaron A. Herbert, PC. related to your legal inquiry, case updates, appointments, and other client communications. Message and data rates may apply. Message frequency varies. Reply STOP to unsubscribe or HELP for assistance. Consent to receive texts is not a condition of hiring the firm or receiving legal services. View our SMS Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy for more information.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Aaron Herbert legal resources

Knowledge Hubs

Explore our guides to Texas injury claims and the questions that matter to your case.

Type at least 2 characters. Use arrow keys to choose a result and Enter to open it.

    Browse Knowledge Hubs
    • Store injuries

      Texas Walmart Injury Knowledge Hub

      Explore evidence, liability, damages and litigation for Walmart injury claims in Texas.Explore the hub →
    • Choosing counsel

      TBLS Certified Personal Injury Knowledge Hub

      Understand Board Certification in Personal Injury Trial Law and the questions to ask when choosing counsel.Explore the hub →
    • Truck accident evidence

      Texas Truck Accident Litigation

      Find guidance on truck inspections, electronic records, responsible companies and Texas trial rules.Explore the hub →
    • Damages and settlement

      Texas Injury Claim Value and Litigation

      Learn how evidence, responsibility, medical losses and insurance affect an injury claim.Explore the hub →
    • Motorcycle crashes

      Texas Motorcycle Accident Attorney Knowledge Hub

      Explore guides to crash evidence, injuries, insurance and choosing a motorcycle accident lawyer in Texas.Explore the hub →
    • Car crashes

      Texas Car Accident Knowledge Hub

      Explore guides to crash evidence, fault, injuries, insurance and resolving a car accident claim in Texas.Explore the hub →
    • Warehouse injuries

      Texas Costco Injury Claims and Litigation Guide

      Explore evidence, notice, liability and litigation for Costco injury claims in Texas.Explore the hub →
    • Store injuries

      Target Injury Knowledge Hub

      Explore evidence, notice, video preservation and litigation for Target fall claims in Texas.Explore the hub →
    • Home improvement store injuries

      Home Depot Injury Knowledge Hub

      Explore evidence, notice, video preservation and litigation for Home Depot fall claims in Texas.Explore the hub →
    • Store injuries

      Ross Dress for Less Injury Knowledge Hub

      Explore evidence, notice, video preservation and litigation for Ross fall claims in Texas.Explore the hub →
    • Grocery store injuries

      Kroger Injury Knowledge Hub

      Explore evidence, notice, video preservation and litigation for Kroger fall claims in Texas.Explore the hub →
    • Grocery store injuries

      Tom Thumb and Albertsons Injury Knowledge Hub

      Explore evidence, notice, video preservation and litigation for Tom Thumb and Albertsons fall claims in Texas.Explore the hub →
    • Grocery store injuries

      Texas La Michoacana Supermarket Injury Knowledge Hub

      What to do first, how store notice is proved, and how a Texas premises claim is built from the evidence.Explore the hub →
    • Grocery store injuries

      Texas H-E-B Injury Knowledge Hub

      What an H-E-B injury claim must prove, and the evidence to save in the first days after a fall.Explore the hub →
    • Grocery store injuries

      Texas Brookshire's Injury Knowledge Hub

      Hurt at a Brookshire's, Super 1 Foods or other BGC store? What to do first and how store notice is proved.Explore the hub →
    • Store injuries

      Texas 7-Eleven Injury Knowledge Hub

      Explore evidence, notice, video preservation and responsibility for 7-Eleven injury claims in Texas.Explore the hub →
    • Store injuries

      Burlington Injury Knowledge Hub

      Explore evidence, notice, video preservation and deadlines for Burlington injury claims in Texas.Explore the hub →
    • Parking lot injuries

      Texas Parking Lot Injury Knowledge Hub

      Who may be responsible, what to do first, how notice and video work, and government-lot deadlines.Explore the hub →
    • Apartment injuries

      Texas Apartment Injury Knowledge Hub

      Who may be liable, how repair notices and deadlines work, and what evidence to save after an apartment injury.Explore the hub →
    • Serious injuries

      Texas Catastrophic Injury and Damages Hub

      Explore guides to severe injuries, lifetime care, lost earning capacity and trial evidence.Explore the hub →
    • Fatal accidents

      Texas Wrongful Death Knowledge Hub

      Understand Texas wrongful death claims, evidence, damages and the litigation process.Explore the hub →
    • Family support

      Wrongful Death and Family Support Center

      Find grief programs, funeral and survivor benefit help, and next steps for Texas families.Visit the center →

    Practice Areas|About Us|Client Testimonials|Blog|Contact
    © The Law Firm Of Aaron A. Herbert, P.C. All rights reserved. Privacy Policy|Sitemap